Should You Cancel Private Health Insurance? The Real Cost in 2026
Thinking about dropping your private health cover? Here's the real financial impact — Medicare Levy Surcharge, Lifetime Health Cover loading, gap costs, and when cancelling actually makes sense.
The Medicare Levy Surcharge: the penalty for high earners without cover
The single biggest financial consequence of cancelling private hospital insurance is the Medicare Levy Surcharge. If your income for MLS purposes exceeds $97,000 as a single or $194,000 as a family, you will pay an additional 1.0% to 1.5% of your taxable income on top of the standard 2% Medicare Levy. At $120,000 income, the MLS costs $1,200 per year (1.0% rate). At $140,000, it jumps to $1,750 (1.25% rate). At $180,000, you are looking at $2,700 per year (1.5% rate). The MLS income test includes your taxable income plus reportable fringe benefits, net investment losses, and reportable super contributions — so your MLS income may be higher than the figure on your payslip. For many Australians earning above $97,000, a basic hospital policy after the government rebate costs less than the MLS penalty alone, making cancellation financially counterproductive regardless of whether you ever claim.
Lifetime Health Cover loading: the cost of re-joining later
If you cancel your hospital cover now and decide to rejoin later, you will face Lifetime Health Cover loading. The loading is calculated at 2% of the base premium for every year you were aged over 30 without hospital cover. If you are currently 35 and have held cover since 30, cancelling now means that if you rejoin at age 45, you will pay a 30% loading on your premiums (15 years over 30 without cover, times 2%). On a $2,000 base annual premium, that is an extra $600 per year — and you must pay the loading for 10 continuous years before it is removed. Over a decade, that adds up to $6,000 in additional costs. The loading also applies on top of any premium increases during that period. If you are considering cancelling, factor in the realistic likelihood that you will want or need private cover again in the future, particularly as you age and the public hospital waiting lists for elective procedures grow longer.
What Medicare actually covers — and what it does not
Australia's Medicare system covers the full cost of treatment in public hospitals as a public patient, bulk-billed GP visits, and a proportion of out-of-hospital services listed on the Medicare Benefits Schedule. However, there are significant gaps. As a public patient, you have no choice of doctor, no choice of hospital, and you join the elective surgery waiting list — which can mean months or even years for procedures like hip replacements, knee reconstructions, or cataract surgery. Medicare does not cover private hospital rooms, dental care (except some child dental through CDBS), most optical services beyond standard eye tests, physiotherapy beyond limited GP-referred sessions, psychology beyond the Mental Health Treatment Plan sessions, or ambulance services in most states. It also does not cover the gap between the MBS fee and what specialists actually charge — and that gap has been growing rapidly, with many specialists charging 200-400% above the MBS fee for consultations and procedures.
Gap payments and out-of-pocket costs without insurance
Even with Medicare, going without private health insurance can expose you to substantial out-of-pocket costs. If you need surgery and choose to go private to avoid the public waiting list, you will face the full hospital accommodation fee (typically $800-$2,000 per night), the surgeon's fee, anaesthetist's fee, and any prostheses or implant costs. A straightforward knee arthroscopy can cost $5,000-$8,000 out of pocket. A hip replacement runs $18,000-$25,000. Having a baby in a private hospital without cover costs $8,000-$15,000 depending on the birth type and length of stay. Even in the public system, you may face gap costs for pathology, imaging, and specialist consultations where providers do not bulk bill. The proportion of specialists who bulk bill has been declining steadily — in some areas, fewer than 30% of specialists offer no-gap services. These unpredictable costs are the core risk you take on when cancelling private hospital cover.
When cancelling health insurance actually makes sense
Cancelling private health insurance can be a rational financial decision in specific circumstances. The strongest case exists for singles earning under $97,000 (or families under $194,000) who face no Medicare Levy Surcharge penalty. If you are generally healthy, have no planned medical procedures, are comfortable using the public hospital system, and you are under 31 (so no LHC loading risk), cancelling and redirecting the premiums into a dedicated health savings fund can work well. Similarly, if you are only holding a basic hospital policy purely to avoid the MLS, but your income drops below the threshold due to reduced work hours, parental leave, or career change, dropping the policy saves you money with no surcharge consequence. Retirees on lower incomes who have paid off their LHC loading may also find that self-insuring makes sense if their super balance can absorb unexpected medical costs. Always check your income for MLS purposes before cancelling — it includes components beyond your salary.
Alternatives to cancelling: downgrade to basic hospital cover
If you are paying too much but do not want to lose cover entirely, downgrading is often the smarter move. A Basic or Bronze hospital policy with a $750 excess can cost as little as $80-$120 per month for a single after the government rebate — substantially less than Gold or Silver cover. This approach keeps you MLS-exempt, preserves your Lifetime Health Cover status (no loading if you rejoin a higher tier later), and still provides a safety net for emergency hospitalisations and accidents. You can also consider dropping your extras cover while keeping hospital — extras policies typically cost $30-$60 per month, and if you are not regularly claiming on dental, optical, or physio, paying out of pocket for occasional visits may be cheaper. Another option is switching to a fund that offers lower premiums for equivalent cover — many people stick with the same fund for years without realising they could save hundreds by switching. Use our Budget Planner to map out your health insurance costs against your other expenses and find the right balance.
Try these free tools
Official resources
General information and estimates only — not financial, tax, or legal advice. Always verify with a licensed adviser or the ATO.
Related articles
Understand the 2% Medicare levy, the surcharge for high earners without private health, and the income thresholds that determine what you pay.
Private Health Insurance Rebate 2025-26: How Much You Get Back by IncomeComplete guide to the Australian Government Private Health Insurance Rebate for 2025-26. Rebate percentages by age and income tier, how to claim, and the Medicare Levy Surcharge you'll pay without cover.
Medicare Levy Surcharge: Who Pays It & How to Avoid ItUnderstand the Medicare Levy Surcharge — income thresholds, rates from 1% to 1.5%, how private health insurance exempts you, and the difference between the MLS and the standard Medicare levy.
Private Health Insurance Rebate 2025-26: Do You Need Private Cover?Understand the private health insurance rebate, Medicare Levy Surcharge, and whether private health insurance is worth it in Australia for 2025-26. Includes income thresholds and rebate tiers.